1952-53

Hill 0 – 8 Peddie

0 – 4 Peddie

5 – 4 Morristown School

1 – 5 Lehigh

0 – 10 Lawrenceville

1953-54

Hill 3 – 5 St. Marks

12 – 1 Peddie

1 – 2 Morristown School

10 – 1 Peddie

4 – 1 Storm King

4 – 3 Lawrenceville

5 – 4 Lehigh Fr.

1 – 3 Ridgewood YMCA

0 – 3 Hershey

1954-55

Hill 2 – 0 St. Marks

0 – 3 Lawrenceville

1 – 2 Morristown School

0 – 2 Princeton Fr.

6 – 1 Hill Alumni

3 – 4 Hershey

4 – 2 Storm King

1 – 0 Morristown School

2 – 2 Lawrenceville

5 – 3 Lehigh

4 – 6 Lansdowne HC

12 – 2 Peddie

1 – 11 Northwood

1955-56

Hill 1 – 2 St. Marks

6 – 3 Forest Park HS

0 – 0 Northwood

8 – 3 Calvert Hall

3 – 1 Morristown School

3 – 3 Princeton Fr.

6 – 1 Lehigh Fr

4 – 0 Hershey

1 – 0 Hill Alumni

4 – 2 Morristown School

5 – 2 Loomis

2 – 7 Lawrenceville

1956-57

Hill 1 – 2 St. Marks

8 – 0 Morristown School

1 – 7 Princeton Fr.

1 – 2 Lawrenceville

5 – 0 Trinity Pawling

8 – 7 Choate

5 – 1 Hershey

1 – 2 Lawrenceville

6 – 0 Lehigh JV

8 – 2 Morristown School

8 – 1 Loomis

1957-58

Hill 2 – 3 St. Marks

6 – 3 Chestnut Hill

0 – 9 Princeton Fr.

16 – 0 Storm King

5 – 1 Morristown School

1 – 6 West Point Fr.

2 – 2 Wissahickon Srs.

4 – 0 Hershey

4 – 2 Loomis

7 – 0 Lehigh JV

6 – 2 Morristown School

2 – 5 Lawrenceville

7 – 3 Trinity Pawling

1958-59

Hill 0 – 9 St. Marks

1 – 2 Hershey

5 – 1 Chestnut Hill

6 – 3 Morristown School

3 – 4 Wissahickon Srs.

2 – 4 Princeton Fr

2 – 4 Loomis

8 – 2 Lehigh

0 – 2 Cornell Fr.

14 – 1 Valley Forge HC

0 – 5 Lawrenceville

12 – 1 Morristown School

3 – 2 Trinity Pawling (OT)

1959-60

Hill 4 – 9 St. Marks

3 – 3 Hershey

2 – 11 Cornell Fr.

7 – 4 Chestnut Hill

2 – 4 Wissahickon Srs.

0 – 7 Princeton Fr.

3 – 2 Loomis

5 – 1 Lehigh

1 – 7 Taft

3 – 4 Lawrenceville

5 – 1 Morristown School

9 – 0 Summit HC