1960-61

Hill 1 – 7 St. Marks

3 – 4 Choate

0 – 6 Lawrenceville

9 – 0 Morris Hills HS

1 – 7 Hershey

6 – 2 Beacon Hill HC

6 – 2 Chestnut Hill

5 – 3 Wissahickon Srs.

5 – 6 Princeton Fr. (OT)

3 – 3 Loomis

7 – 2 Lehigh

14 – 1 Livingston HS

1 – 7 Lawrenceville

10 – 0 Mooristown School

4 – 7 Franklin&Marshall

13 – 1 Paioli Falcons

1961-62

Hill 11 – 1 Villanova

0 – 3 Deerfield

2 – 5 Burrillville HS

4 – 7 Lawrenceville

4 – 1 Hershey

2 – 3 Woonsocket HS

10 – 3 Wissahickon Jr.

3 – 2 Lancaster HC

5 – 2 Beacon Hill HC

4 – 2 Continentals

3 – 6 Loomis

3 – 1 Lehigh

6 – 7 Wissahickon Srs.

3 – 3 Lawrenceville

2 – 3 Franklin&Marshall

2 – 12 Princeton Fr.

5 – 1 Paioli Falcons

1 – 1 Cranford HC

1962-63

Hill 6 – 0 Villanova

2 – 5 Hershey

5 – 1 Wissahickon Jr.

4 – 3 Woonsocket HS

7 – 0 Lancaster HC

15 – 0 Lower Makefield HC

2 – 1 Lawrenceville

3 – 9 Loomis

5 – 1 Lehigh

3 – 1 Wissahickson Jr.

3 – 1 Lafayette

3 – 2 Lawrenceville (OT)

4 – 1 Summit HC

5 – 0 Bucknell

8 – 2 Franklin&Marshall

3 – 1 Wissahickon Jr.

2 – 4 Cranford HC

1963-64

Hill 6 – 3 Villanova

2 – 1 St. Marks

9 – 0 Hershey

3 – 2 Franklin&Marshall

4 – 2 South Orange

3 – 4 Wissahickon Jr.

1 – 2 Lawrenceville

4 – 3 Loomis

6 – 2 Lehigh

8 – 1 Wissahickon Jr.

3 – 1 Lafayette

2 – 3 Lawrenceville (OT)

3 – 5 Princeton Fr.

6 – 1 Summit HC

5 – 2 Summit HC

4 – 1 Cranford HC

1964-65

Hill 2 – 0 Wissahickon Jr.

3 – 4 St. Marks (OT)

7 – 1 Lehigh

5 – 3 Hershey

2 – 4 Woonsocket HS

9 – 2 Main Line HC

3 – 4 Wissahickon Jr.

1 – 2 South Orange

4 – 1 Lawrenceville

4 – 0 Loomis

4 – 1 Villanova

7 – 3 Summit HC

5 – 1 Lafayette

8 – 2 Cranford HC

2 – 5 Princeton Fr.

5 – 4 Lawrenceville

3 – 5 Franklin&Marshall

4 – 2 Summit HC

4 – 3 Wissahickon Jr.

4 – 6 Beacon Hill HC

1965-66

Hill 8 – 2 Lehigh

7 – 1 Gen. Washington

4 – 1 Hershey

9 – 4 Trinity Pawling

6 – 1 Wissahickon Jr.

9 – 2 South Orange

3 – 0 Lawrenceville

4 – 5 Loomis

10 – 0 Villanova

3 – 1 Woonsocket HS

2 – 3 Mt. St. Charles (OT)

5 – 0 Lafayette

3 – 2 Cranford HC

2 – 3 Princeton Fr.

3 – 2 Lawrenceville (OT)

2 – 3 Penn Fr.

3 – 4 Wissahickon Jr.

6 – 1 Summit HC

1966-67

Hill 8 – 0 Lehigh

7 – 5 Westminster

1 – 6 Milton

5 – 3 Salisbury

0 – 2 Trinity Pawling

5 – 1 Hershey

2 – 6 Princeton Fr.

14 – 0 Gen. Washington

0 – 3 Wissahickon Jr.

5 – 0 South Orange

1 – 2 Loomis

8 – 1Villanova

4 – 1 Woonsocket HS

5 – 7 Mt. St. Charles

3 – 0 Lafayette

2 – 1 Cranford HC

3 – 0 Lawrenceville

5 – 4 Penn Fr. (OT)

3 – 2 Cranford HC (OT)

4 – 3 Wissahickon Jr.

1967-68

Hill 1 – 4 Milton

2 – 0 Westminster

1 – 3 Deerfield

1 – 4 Kent

0 – 6 Trinity Pawling

3 – 1 Hershey

0 – 8 Penn Fr.

4 – 3 Wissahickon Jr. (OT)

10 – 2 South Orange

0 – 3 Lawrenceville

9 – 2 Loomis

4 – 0 Villanova

4 – 2 Princeton Day School

2 – 2 Cranford HC

9 – 1 Lafayette

4 – 2 Lawrenceville

2 – 5 Princeton Fr.

3 – 1 Wissahickon Jr.

3 – 4 PDS (OT)

1968-69

Hill 3 – 1 Lehigh

1 – 6 Taft

1 – 2 Moses Brown

1 – 2 Nobles

4 – 3 Hershey

0 – 6 Penn Fr.

3 – 2 Wissahickson Jr.

4 – 5 Trinity Pawling

12 – 0 Villanova

2 – 5 Loomis

0 – 3 Kent

4 – 1 South Orange

3 – 2 PDS

9 – 1 Cranford HC

0 – 1 Lawrenceville

6 – 1 Bryn Athen

1 – 4 Princeton Fr.

0 – 5 Englewood HC

2 – 3 Lawrenceville (OT)

3 – 1 Cranford HC

5 – 3 Wissahickon Jr.

1969-70

Hill 3 – 0 Lehigh

0 – 2 Nobles

5 – 2 Hotchkiss

1 – 2 Milton

2 – 0 Hershey

0 – 3 Penn Fr.

1 – 0 Wissahickon Jr.

1 – 4 Trinity Pawling

0 – 3 Kent

6 – 1 Loomis

3 – 2 PDS (OT)

1 – 9 Princeton Fr.

6 – 1 South Orange

6 – 0 Cranford HC

4 – 0 Lawrenceville

4 – 5 Lawrenceville

3 – 4 Hershey (OT)

7 – 0 Cranford HC

8 – 2 Beacon Hill HC